Fed Chairman Warsh says Board staff are modeling scenarios for how super intelligence could change the economy
Opening a Fed conference in San Francisco, Kevin Warsh said the technology will have important implications for monetary policy and outlined staff scenarios, from broad productivity gains to falling equity valuations.
Federal Reserve Chairman Kevin Warsh said on Monday, November 16, that the Board’s staff have begun evaluating scenarios for how “super intelligence” could reshape the US economy, and that its widespread adoption will have important implications for monetary policy down the road.
Warsh spoke at the opening of the Productivity and Jobs Task Force Conference, hosted by the Federal Reserve Board and the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. He said it was his first visit to a Reserve Bank as Chairman, and that the task force is one of five he has convened.
The staff scenarios
Warsh said the staff are using stylized, model-based frameworks and stressed that the results are illustrative and not forecasts. He described three kinds of outcome:
- Broad gains. Productivity rises and the gains are shared across workers and the owners of capital; real GDP growth stays above its long-run average and the economy stays close to full employment.
- Disruptive growth. GDP growth still rises above its long-term average, but automation displaces some jobs and, with labor market frictions, pushes unemployment above levels consistent with full employment.
- Disappointment. After heavy capital investment and stock market gains, expected returns turn down and equity valuations fall, leading to a slowdown and a more notable rise in unemployment; the economy recovers in time, but without the productivity gains.
What he said about policy
Warsh said the Fed is neither advocating for nor opposing the technology, and that the big questions are about the magnitude, scope and timing of any productivity surge. He said productivity growth has been reasonably strong in recent quarters but has not yet broken out definitively and structurally to the upside. He also said the Fed is thinking about risks to critical infrastructure, because the technology empowers bad actors as well.
“These are illustrative scenarios, not forecasts,” Warsh said of the staff work.
For traders
The remarks did not discuss the federal funds rate or the next policy decision. They show the questions the Fed Chairman is putting on the agenda: whether productivity gains arrive, how fast, and what that means for jobs and growth. One of the staff’s own scenarios includes falling equity valuations after a period of stock market gains.
Markets: Stocks